Israel, November 2015
A couple of days after arriving in Israel, I realized something was different; My friends and family were all ready to pack their bags and leave. My best friend jokingly told my partner, “When the time comes, you will divorce her and marry me.” My aunt, though desperately missing her son who lives in the United States, told me she was happy he was starting a family “there” and not “here.” At some point I was at a large dinner party in which everyone agreed that “the experiment called Israel is going to end.” They merely disagreed on how and when. The most optimistic gave it fifteen years. The pessimistic, five.
As if to echo my perceptions, Tahel Prosh wrote in Haaretz a piece titled in Hebrew, “How do you know when it’s too late to leave?” The English title is different. In it, she describes her grandfather’s emotional relationship with a packet of old letters from his family before the war, in which they begged him to rescue them from Germany and get them a passport to Palestine. He tried his best and failed. It was already too late to leave. Prosh wonders whether she would know when it would already be too late leave Israel.
At the end of the piece, seeking reasons to stay in the country, Prosh refers back to a list she had run across on a website written by and intended for teenagers: “64 Reasons to Stay in Israel”
The list’s author explained that she had compiled it because it bugged her that her friends talked about leaving the country. Among the reasons to stay she wrote:
“Because we don’t have curfew; when there is a war we are all united; because it is very hard to obtain citizenship in other places; because Israel is the only place where you can drive a tank at the age of 18; because only in Israel we’re all brothers.” And she also wrote: “Because the Land of Israel is beautiful and flourishing; because the climate is pleasant in every season and because there is no place in the world like the promenade in Tel Aviv.”
Imagine the teenage girl so frustrated that her entire world is collapsing. Everyone around her speaks of leaving, and she needs to imagine a future elsewhere, speaking a language she probably doesn’t know very well. She sits in her room and writes this list for Israel’s Independence Day. And the result is so very unconvincing, somewhat pathetic, and even sad.
It isn’t so much that people I talked to were afraid for their own safety. The threat of terrorism is not a push factor. It is rather a sense of despair that brings about what I would call a mystical eschatology. People feel things are getting continuously worse and have come to believe that it somehow must end. It simply cannot continue. Most of my friends feel they have no control over the political reality and don’t believe the next election will make things better. Instead, they deeply believe something cataclysmic will bring it all to a crashing end. The Freudian death drive is superimposed on the entire nation.
When I asked what would cause the end of the Israel-experiment and about the inevitable doomsday scenario everyone was referring to, people gave multiple answers. Some of my liberal friends argued that the Occupation simply cannot continue. The Israeli public has been refusing to see that it is resting on the barrel of explosives that could erupt at any moment. This feeling gave additional zest to the recent violence. It proved the liberal argument that we cannot keep millions under occupation and expect to get away with it.
Others believed that ISIS would be Israel’s doom. “There is a civil war ravaging a country less than a hundred miles from here!” they told me.
But most often I listened to a detailed explanation of the “demographic revolution,” which reflects an analytical mixture of President Rivlin’s lament of the lost “Israeli identity” and the growth of tribal identity with Aluf Benn’s subsequent analysis of the “demographic revolution.” Israel’s secular form is rapidly giving way to its religious content.
A generation ago, 60 percent of Israeli children learned in secular state schools. Two years ago just 41.5 percent of first-graders attended those schools. Looking forward, the number of ultra-Orthodox first-graders and Arab first-graders will grow by 4.3 percent and 2.5 percent respectively, while the number of secular first-graders will contract slightly, comprising 37.2 percent of their cohort in four years.
Of course, all three explanations are evidence-based and fairly reasonable. The combination of the three with a deep sense of despair and lack of agency turn them into what I consider a mystical eschatology. But this is eschatology with a twist — while in the final battle, the forces of good will fight the forces of evil and the righteous will be victorious, in Israel today, those who consider themselves good are opting to quit the battlefield and save their skins. This is the true danger to the experiment called Israel.
Maya, Shalom. I left Israel five years ago after having lived there for nearly 30 years (in Jerusalem.) I was getting ready to leave for several years because I felt I was being broken-hearted to death there. The suffering of both peoples, and the apathy of my fellow Israelis to both the cruelty of the Occupation and for just basic Jewish values became too much to bear, day after day. While volunteering with Rabbis for Human Rights (almost the only reason that I still identify as a Jew), I accompanied Palestinian farmers in Sinjil to protect them from attacks from settlers, I ended up with a knee so badly broken that it put an end to my tour guiding career there. I took it as a sign that it was time to leave. So, here I am, in the States, literally weeping over the misbegotten and doomed “experiment” of Zionism. If only there were some way to make reparations somehow, but I am afraid it’s too late. I never thought I’d live to see this day.
I lived and worked in Israel on and off over a period of `10 years. My last stay was 1970-74, when I started the Women’s movement in Tel Aviv. Now I am with Women in Black, every Thursday on Union Square from 5:30-6:30. I have many relatives in Israel since my grandfather founded Kfar Baruch after WWI. I worry about all of them all the time because of the loss of the ethics of the original values, as well as the consequences that are likely to happen as a result of the Occupation policies.
This piece and the comments are so insightful. Many of us have been thinking about how ISRAEL seems to be becoming more suicidal every day but don’t really talk about it. What will be the straw that breaks the camel’s backache? What will the end look like? The madness of the ultra orthodox and the settlers cannot create any kind of a society that resembles a nonviolent peace loving democracy or embraces universal Justice – the essence of Judaism for me.