Meretz USA Statement on Ending the Violence

Meretz USA Statement on Ending the Violence

The brazen murder of eight yeshiva students, mostly teenagers, in a landmark mainstream Orthodox institution in Jerusalem, has convulsed Israel in sadness and outrage. That this has occurred within a week of the massive operation in the Gaza Strip, killing about 120 Palestinians, is no accident. About half, if not more, of this latter toll were of fighters of the terrorist factions, but dozens were non-combatant civilians, including children.

The intent of the attackers was not the same in these two cases. Israel was attempting to end the ongoing rocket attacks on southern Israel; it did not target civilian victims. The lone terrorist in Jerusalem did exactly that.

Still, there is a “cycle of violence,” a term that offends many supporters of Israel because it seems to imply a moral equivalence between acts of terror and efforts to end them. We make no such argument. Israel’s intentions to defend itself are justified, but the carnage exacted upon Palestinians is much greater, generally by a large order of magnitude. Clearly, these tactics do not work; violence begets violence.

The only way out is through a ceasefire on the ground and a renewed effort to negotiate a peaceful end to the conflict, a viable two-state solution. President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority has offered to broker a truce between Israel and Hamas; Egypt’s good offices might also facilitate an indirect negotiation for such a result.

We implore that Israel not allow the terrorists to win by vetoing the possibility of peace. We commend Prime Minister Olmert’s announced intention to continue the peace talks with the Palestinian Authority and urge every effort toward a breakthrough.

By | 2008-03-07T14:34:00-05:00 March 7th, 2008|Blog|2 Comments


  1. Anonymous March 15, 2008 at 3:19 pm - Reply

    Hi Ralph,

    Meretz USA has really pushed forward an insightful analysis of what is happening in Israel and Palestine here.

    Perhaps Meretz USA would also like to denounce the cycle of violence in Tibet as well, hard as it may be for many Chinese to accept this analysis:

    Seems like the Chinese authorities are only aiming to defend themselves, though perhaps they too are using disproportionate force. There seem to be many parallels.


  2. Ralph Seliger March 15, 2008 at 6:42 pm - Reply

    There are clear parallels between the China-Tibet situation and that of Israel-Palestine. But China is an immense country and an enormous power in ways that Israel can only envy. And unlike Israel in the West Bank, China did not conquer Tibet because it was part of a hostile military coalition arrayed against it.

    But similarities exist. We have enough on our plate with the Middle East, however, without pronouncing on this other issue that is beyond our mandated focus.

Leave A Comment